The russian revolution of 1917 centers around two
primary events:February revolution and October revolution .The february
revolution which removed Tsar Nicholas II from power devoloped
spontaneously out of a serious of increasingly violent demonstrations
and riots on the streets Petrograd during a time when tsar was away from
the capital visiting troops on the world war I front.
The October
Revolution overtuned the interim provisional government and established
the soviet union.It was a much more deliberate event orchestrated by a
small group of people.The Bolsheviks who led this coup, prepared their
coup in only six months.By october,the bolsheviks popular base was much
popular,they had built up a majority of support with Petrograd and other
urban
centres.Liberals, Racials and Coservatives
Liberals: Liberals wanted a
change in the society. They wanted toleration towards all religions.
They opposed the uncontrolled power of dynastic rulers. They wanted to
safeguard the rights of individuals. They favoured a representative,
elected parliamentary government. Such a government should be subject to
laws interpreted by a well-trained and independent judiciary. However,
some of the liberal ideas were not democratic. They did not believe in
universal adult franchise and wanted the voting rights only for men with
property.
Radicals: Radicals also wanted a
change in the society. The radicals were in favour of women’s suffragate
movement. They opposed the privileges of wealthy landowners and factory
owners. They were not against private property but opposed the
concentration of property in a few hands.
Conservatives: The conservatives
preferred the status quo. However, their attitudes changed after the
French Revolution. They were in favour of gradual change; with some
preservation of old institutions.
Industrial Society and Social Change
Industrialization resulted in a large number of people working in
factories. Work hours were usually long and the workers were getting
poor wages. Unemployment was quite common. As towns were growing
rapidly, there were problems of housing and sanitation.
Many among the liberals and radicals were property owners and
employers. They wanted the benefit of industrialization to reach the
workforce. They believed that healthy and educated citizens would be
more productive for the economy. Some liberals and radicals wanted
revolutions which could end all kind of governments established in
Europe in 1815.
The Coming of Socialism to Europe
Socialism was a radical idea which was based on abolition of private
properties and projected a dream of classless society. Socialists saw
private property as the root of all social ills. They argued that the
capitalists were only concerned about their profit and not with the
welfare of workers.
Some socialists believed in the idea of cooperatives. Some other
socialists believed that the governments should encourage cooperatives
because it was not possible to build large-scale cooperatives by
individual initiatives.
Karl Marx (1818-1883) argued that workers should make a cooperative
society in which collective ownership of land and factories would be
promoted. According to Marx, it was the way to get rid of ills of
capitalism. Friedrich Engels (1820-1895) also added other ideas to the
concept of socialism.
Support for Socialism
Socialist ideas spread through Europe by the 1870s. An international
body; called Second International was formed to coordinate these
efforts.
Workers in England and Germany began forming associations so that
they could fight for better living and working conditions. They also set
up funds to help members in times of distress. They demanded reduced
working hours and the voting rights. These associations worked closely
with the Social Democratic Party (SPD) in Germany and helped it in
winning the parliamentary seats. Similarly, a Labour Party was formed in
Britain and a Socialist Party was formed in France by 1905. However,
till 1914, the socialists did not succeed in forming a government in
Europe.
THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
The fall of monarchy in February 1917 and the subsequent events of October are normally called the Russian Revolution.
The Russian Empire in 1914
In 1914, Russia and its empire was ruled by Tsar Nicholas II. The
Russian empire included modern-day Finland, Latvia, Lithuania, and
Estonia, parts of Poland, Ukraine and Belarus. It stretched to the
Pacific and comprised modern day Central Asian states, as well as
Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan.
Orthodox Christianity was the majority religion in Russia but
Catholics, Protestants, Muslims and Buddhists also lived in the Russian
Empire.
Economy and Society
At the beginning of the twentieth century, about 85% of the Russian
empire’s population was dependent on agriculture. Industry was found in
some pockets; like St. Petersburg and Moscow. Much of the production was
done by craftsmen but large factories also existed. Most of the
factories were set up in the 1890s. This was the period when Russia’s
railway network was extended and foreign investment in industry
increased.
Most of the industry was owned by private individuals. The government
kept an eye on large factories to ensure minimum wages and limited
working hours. But rules were broken with impunity. Workers sometimes
had to work up to 15 hours. Accommodation for workers could be in rooms
or dormitories.
Workers: The workers were divided
into different social groups. Some of them had strong links with their
ancestral villages. Some others had permanently settled in the cities.
Workers were divided by skill and metalworkers were on top of this
hierarchy. Workers’ dress and manners also manifested such divisions.
In spite of divisions, the workers often united to strike work
whenever there was some issue related to dismissals or work conditions.
Such strikes frequently took place in the textiles industry during
1896-1897, and in the metal industry during 1902.
Peasants: In villages, the
peasants cultivated most of the land, but large properties were owned by
the nobility, the crown and the Orthodox Church.
Barring a few exceptions, the peasants had no respect for the
nobility. Nobles enjoyed their power and position because of their
services to the Tsar. The peasants of Russia wanted the land of the
nobles to be given to them. They often refused to pay rent and even
murdered landlords. Such incidents occurred on a large scale in south
Russia in 1902. And in 1905, such incidents happened all over Russia.
Russian peasants pooled their land together periodically. Their
commune (mir) divided the land according to the needs of individual
families. Thus, they had a long tradition of working in close
association.
Liberals, Racials and Coservatives
SOCIALISM IN RUSSIA
Some Russian socialists felt that the Russian peasant tradition of
sharing the land according to commune (mir) made them natural
socialists. They felt that peasants, rather than workers, would be the
main force behind the revolution. They felt that Russia could become
socialist more quickly than other countries.
Socialists were active in the countryside through the late nineteenth
century. The Socialist Revolutionary Party was formed in 1900. This
party demanded that land of the nobles should be transferred to
peasants.
Social Democrats did not agree with Socialist Revolutionaries about
peasants’ rights. Lenin thought that peasants were not one united group
and hence they could all be part of a socialist movement.
Lenin thought that the party should be disciplined and should control
the number and quality of its members. Others (Mensheviks) thought that
the party should be open to all; as in Germany.
A Turbulent Time: The 1905 Revolution
The Tsar was not answerable to parliament. The liberals in Russia;
along with the Social Democrats and Socialist Revolutionaries; worked
with peasants and workers during the revolution of 1905 to demand a
constitution. They were also supported in the empire by nationalists and
by jadidists (in Muslim dominated areas). The jadidists wanted
modernized Islam in their lives.
1904 was a bad year for Russian workers. Prices of essential goods
arose so quickly that real wages declined by 20 percent. The membership
of workers’ associations increased dramatically. The Assembly of Russian
Workers was formed in 1904. When four of its members were dismissed at
the Putilov Iron Works, there was a call for industrial action. Over
110,000 workers in St. Petersburg went on strike within a few days. They
were demanding an eight hour work-schedule, increase in wages and
improved working conditions.
Bloody Sunday:
Father Gapon led the procession of workers. When the procession reached
the Winter Palace, it was attacked by the police and the Cossacks. Over
100 workers were killed and 300 injured. This incident is known as
Bloody Sunday. It started a serried of events which came to be known as
the 1905 Revolution.
Strikes took place all over the country. Student bodies staged
walkouts and universities were closed down. Lawyers, doctors, engineers
and other middle-class workers formed the Union of Unions. They demanded
a constituent assembly.
Creation of Duma:
The Tsar allowed the creation of an elected consultative Parliament
(Duma). Most of the committees and unions which were formed during this
period were declared illegal after 1905 and hence many of them continued
to work unofficially.
The Tsar imposed several restrictions on political activity. The
first Duma was dismissed within 75 day and the re-elected second Duma
was dismissed within three months. The Tsar then changed the voting laws
and the third Duma was packed with conservative politicians.
The First World War and the Russian Empire
The War was initially popular and people rallied around Tsar Nicholas
II. But the Tsar refused to consult the main parties in the Duma; when
the war continued. This led to reduced support for the Tsar.
Defeat of Russian Army: The War on the ‘eastern front’ was different
from the War on the ‘western front’. The armies fought from trenches
along the eastern France; in the west. On the other hand, the armies
moved a good deal on the east and fought battles. Casualties were high
on the eastern front. Russia’s armies lost badly in Germany and Austria
between 1914 and 1916. By 1917, over 7 million people died in the
battle.
The retreating Russian army destroyed crops and buildings. The
destruction of crops and buildings resulted in 3 million refugees in
Russia. This development tarnished the image of the Tsar. Soldiers did
not wish to fight such a war.
Effect on Industry: Industry was
also badly affected by the war. German control of the Baltic Sea
resulted in supplies being cut off to Russia. Due to this, industrial
equipments disintegrated more rapidly in Russia than anywhere else in
Europe. Railway lines began to break down by 1916. There was shortage of
labour because the able-bodied men had been called for the war duty.
This led to small workshops being shut and resulted in shortage of
essential items. Large supplies of grains were sent to feed the army.
Riots at bread shops were a common sight by the winter of 1916.
In the winter of 1917, conditions in the capital, Petrograd, were
grim. Food shortages were severe in the workers’ quarters. The winter
was very cold; accompanied by frost and heavy snow.
February Revolution:
On 22 February, a lockout took place at a factory on the right bank
of the Neva river. On the next day, workers in fifty factories went on
strike to show solidarity. Women led the way to strikes in many
factories.
The demonstrators crossed from the factory quarters to the centre of
the capital; the Nevskii Prospekt. The movement was not being actively
organized by any political party. The government imposed a curfew and
the demonstrators dispersed by the evening. But they came back on the
24th and 25th. Cavalry and police were called to keep a watch on the
demonstrators.
The government suspended the Duma on 25th February. Demonstrators
returned in larger number to the streets of the left bank on the 26th
February. The Police Headquarters were ransacked on 27th February.
The government once again called out the cavalry to control the
situation. But the cavalry refused to fire on the demonstrators. An
officer of a regiment was shot at and three other regiments mutinied to
join the striking workers.
By the evening of 27th February, soldiers and striking workers
gathered to form a ‘soviet’ or ‘council’ in the same building as the
Duma met. This was the Petrograd Soviet.
A delegation went to see the Tsar on 28th February. The Tsar abdicated on 2nd March; on the advice of the military.
A provisional government was formed by the Soviet Leaders and the
Duma leaders. Thus the February Revolution of 1917 brought down the
monarchy in Russia.
After February
The Provisional Government took steps towards an elected government.
Restrictions on public meetings and associations were removed. ‘Soviets’
were set up everywhere, though no common system of election was
followed.
Return of Lenin: The Bolshevik leader Vladimir Lenin returned from
exile in April 1917. He made three demands which were known as ‘April
Theses’. He declared an end to the war, transfer of land to the peasants
and nationalization of banks. He proposed renaming of the Bolshevik
Party as the Communist Party; to indicate its new radical aims.
Most others in the Bolshevik Party thought that the time was not ripe
for socialist revolution. They wanted the Provisional Government to
continue for some time. But various developments in the subsequent
months changed their mindset.
The workers’ movement spread through the summer. Trade unions grew in
number; in industrial areas. Soldiers’ committees were formed in the
army. In the month of June, about 500 Soviets sent representatives to an
All Russian Congress of Soviets.
The provisional government viewed these developments are an erosion
in its powers and as growing influence of Bolshevik. The Provisional
Government decided to take stern measures. The demonstrations by the
Bolsheviks in July 1917 were sternly repressed. Many Bolshevik leaders
had to go hiding. Many of them fled as well.
The peasants and their Socialist Revolutionary leaders demanded a
redistribution of land. The peasants seized land between July and
September 1917.
Liberals, Racials and Coservatives
THE REVOLUTION OF OCTOBER 1917
Lenin was apprehensive of imposition of dictatorship by the
Provisional Government. On 16 October 1917, he convinced the Petrograd
Soviet and the Bolshevik Party to agree to a socialist seizure of power.
A Military Revolutionary Committee was appointed by the Soviet under
Leon Trotskii to organize the seizure.
The uprising began on 24 October. Prime Minister Kerenskii had sensed
trouble and hence left the city to summon troops. In the morning,
military men loyal to the government seized the buildings of two
Bolshevik newspapers. Pro-government troops were sent to take over the
telephone and telegraph offices and protect the Winter Palace.
The Military Revolutionary Committee
moved swiftly and ordered its supporters to seize government offices
and arrest ministers. Later in the day, the ship Aurora shelled the
Winter Palace. Various other vessels sailed down the Neva and took over
various military points. The city was under the Committee’s control by
night and the ministers had surrendered. At a meeting of the All Russian
Congress of Soviets in Petrograd, the Bolshevik action was approved by
the majority. By December, the Bolsheviks controlled the
Moscow-Petrograd area.
What Changed after October?
- Most of the industry and banks were nationalized in November 1917. The government took over ownership and management.
- Land was declared social property. Peasants were allowed to seize the land of the nobility.
- In cities, large houses were partitioned as per family requirements.
- Old titles of aristocracy were banned.
- A clothing competition was held in 1918; to design new uniforms for the army and officials.
The Bolshevik Party was renamed the Russian Communist Party (Bolshevik).
Elections for the Constituent Assembly were held in November 1917. The
Bolsheviks failed to get majority after this election. The Assembly
rejected Bolshevik measures and Lenin dismissed the Assembly in January
1918. Lenin thought that the All Russian Congress of Soviets was more
democratic than the Assembly because the Assembly was elected under
uncertain conditions.
In March 1918, the Bolsheviks
made peace with Germany at Brest Litovsk; in spite of opposition by
their political allies. In subsequent years, the Bolsheviks became the
only party to participate in the elections to the All Russian Congress
of Soviets. The All Russian Congress of Soviets became the parliament of
the country.
Russia became a one-party state.
Trade unions were kept under party control. The secret police punished
those who criticized the Bolsheviks. Many writers and artists; who had
earlier rallied behind the party felt disillusioned, because of
censorship being imposed by the Bolsheviks.
The Civil War
After the land distribution order by the Bolsheviks, the Russian army
began to break up. Most of the soldiers had come from farming
background and hence wanted to go home for the redistribution of land.
Non-Bolshevik socialists,
liberals and supporters of autocracy protested the Bolshevik uprising.
Their leaders moved to south Russia. They organized troops to fight the
Bolsheviks (the ‘reds’).
The ‘greens’ (Socialist Revolutionaries) and ‘whites (pro-Tsarists)
controlled most of the Russian empire during 1918 and 1919. They were
backed by French, American, British and Japanese troops. These forces
were worried at the growth of socialism in Russia. A civil war ensued
between these forces and the Bolsheviks.
Supporters of private property; among ‘whites’; took harsh steps with
peasants who had seized land. But such actions led to a loss of popular
support for the non-Bolsheviks.
The Bolsheviks took control of most of the former Russian empire by
January 1920. The succeeded because of cooperation with non-Russian
nationalities and Muslim jadidists.
But the cooperation did not work where Russian colonists themselves
turned Bolshevik. In Khiva (Central Asia), Bolshevik colonists brutally
massacred local nationalists in the name of defending socialism.
Finally, in
December 1922, the Soviet Union (USSR) was formed from the Russian empire.
Most non-Russian nationalities were given political autonomy in this
union to prevent oppression by the Russian colonists. But various
unpopular policies of the Bolsheviks meant that the attempts to win over
different nationalities were only partially successful.
Making a Socialist Society
Planned Economy: A process of
centralised planning was introduced by the Bolshevik. The officials
planned for the development of the economy and made the Five Year Plans.
Industrial growth was the target of the first two ‘Plans’ (1927-32 and
1933-38). Industrial production increased during this period and new
industrial cities came up.
But rapid construction led to poor working conditions. Workers’
quarters were built in haphazard manner; without giving proper attention
to certain facilities. Toilets and other conveniences were often made
across the street from the living quarter. It often made for miserable
life in the bitterly cold weather.
Schools were established for workers’ children and an extended
schooling system was developed for factory workers and peasants. Crèches
were made in factories for the benefit of women workers. Cheap
healthcare was provided by the government.
Stalinism and Collectivisation
The early years of the Planned Economy proved to be disasters for the
collectivization of agriculture. There was acute problem of grain
supplies in the towns in 1927-28. The prices were fixed by the
government but the peasants refused to sell grains to government buyers
at these prices.
This was the time when Stalin was the head of the party. He
introduced firm emergency measures. In 1928, he sent party members to
the grain-producing areas. They supervised enforced collections of
grains. Kulaks (well to do peasants) were raided. But these steps could
not solve the grain crisis.
Stalin’s collectivization programme was then started. From 1929, all
peasants were forced to cultivate in collective farms (kolhoz). The bulk
of land and implements were transferred to the ownership of collective
farm.
Enraged peasants resisted such attempts and destroyed their
livestock. Those who resisted the attempts of collectivization were
severely punished. Many were deported and exiled. After large-scale
protests, some peasants were allowed to work on their independent farms,
but the government was not sympathetic to them.
But collectivization did not produce the desired results. Bad
harvests of 1930-1933 led to one of the most devastating famines in
Soviet history. Over 4 million died in that famine.
Many within the Party who criticized Stalin’s policies were charged
with conspiracy against socialism. By 1939, over 2 milion were in
prisons or in labour camps. A large number were forced to make false
confessions and were executed.
The Global Influence of the Russian Revolution and the USSR
The possibility of a workers’ state fired people’s imagination across
the world, but most of the existing socialist parties in Europe did not
wholly support the policies in Russia. Communist parties were formed in
many countries. By the time, the Second World War began, USSR was
considered to be the global face of socialism.
By the 1950s, many within the country began to acknowledge the fact
that everything was not right in Russia. Although USSR had become a
global industrial power; but basic freedoms were denied to the people.
Many countries adapted to some ideals of socialism, but each country
interpreted them in their own ways.
Liberals, Racials and Coservatives
NCERT Solution
Question – 1- What were the social, economic and political conditions in Russia before 1905?
Answer: A large section of the Russian population was
dependent on agriculture. Some industries had developed in selected
pockets. The Russian empire was under the autocratic rule of the Tsar.
The workers were divided in different social groups, but often united to
strike work in factories. The peasants had a long tradition of working
in commune.
Another Answer:
Question.1: What were
the social, economic and political conditions in Russia before 1905 ?
Solution: The social,
economic and political conditions in Russia were very deplorable before 1905
which brought about a big revolution there known as ‘1905 Revolution’.
At
the beginning of the 20th century about 85% of the Russia’s
population was agriculturists. Russia was a major exporter of grains. Industry
was found in pockets only. Most industries were run by the private
industrialists. Because of wide spread corruption and exploitations, sometimes
workers did not get even the minimum wages and also there was no limit of
working hours. Russia was an autocracy and was ruled by the Tsar. The Tsar,
especially Tsar Nicholas II was a self-willed, corrupt, oppressive ruler. He
ignored public welfare as a result of which the conditions of the peasants and
workers had also become very deplorable. The workers and peasants both were
divided. Peasants frequently refused to pay rent and even murdered landlords.
Being influenced by the democratic experiments by the Western European
countries, the Russians also demanded a responsible government but all their
demands were turned down. Consequently, even the moderate reformers began to
talk of revolutions.
During
the rule of Tsar Nicholas II the privileged had got special rights while the
general public including the workers and farmers had no say in the government.
The situation had become so explosive that even the liberals campaigned to end
this state of affairs. The Russian Social Democratic Workers Party was founded
in 1898 by socialists who respected Marx’s ideas. In 1903, this party was
divided into two groups - Mensheviks and Bolsheviks. The Bolsheviks, who were
in majority, were led by Lenin who is regarded as the greatest thinker on
socialism after Marx.
Question – 2 - In what ways was the working population in Russia different from other countries in Europe, before 1917?
Answer: Compared to other parts of Europe, a larger
portion of the Russian population was engaged in farming. Workers in the
industry had already begun to organize themselves to stop work in
factories. Farmers had a long tradition of working collectively on
farms.
Question – 3 - Why did the Tsarist autocracy collapse in 1917?
Answer: The Tsar first dismissed the initial two Dumas
and then packed the parliament with the conservatives. During the First
World War, the Tsar took decision without consulting the Duma. Large
scale casualties of Russian soldiers in the war further alienated the
people from the Tsar. Burning of crops and buildings by the retreating
Russian armies created huge shortage of food in Russia. All of these led
to the collapse of the Tsarist autocracy in 1917.
Question – 4 - Make two lists: one with the main events and the
effects of the February Revolution and the other with the main events
and effects of the October Revolution. Write a paragraph on who was
involved in each, who were the leaders and what was the impact of each
on Soviet history.
Answer: February Revolution
- On 22 February: A lockout at a factory.
- Demonstrators thronged the centre of the capital, and curfew was imposed.
- 25th February: Suspension of Duma.
- 27th February: Formation of Soviet.
- 2nd March: Tsar leaves power and provisional government formed.
The February Revolution ended the autocratic Tsarist
rule in Russia and paved the way for an elected government. There was no
leader of this movement.
October Revolution:
- 16th October: Formation of Military Revolutionary Committee
- 24th October: Pro-government troops called in to deal with the situation.
- Military Revolutionary Committee controls the city by night and ministers surrender.
- The Bolshevik take control of the power.
The October Revolution was led by Lenin. This event
paved the way for complete control of the Bolsheviks over Russia and the
beginning of a single-party rule.
Question – 5 - What were the main changes brought about by the Bolsheviks immediately after the October Revolution?
Answer: Major changes after the October Revolution:
- Most of the industry and banks were nationalized in November 1917. The government took over ownership and management.
- Land was declared social property. Peasants were allowed to seize the land of the nobility.
- In cities, large houses were partitioned as per family requirements.
- Old titles of aristocracy were banned.
Question – 6 - Write a few lines to show what you know about:
(a) Kulaks
Answer: The wealthy landowners were called the kulaks.
Stalin was suspicious of them for hoarding. During collectivization of
farming, the kulaks were raided and their lands were seized.
(b) The Duma
Answer: The Russian parliament is called the Duma. The first Duma was constituted in 1905.
(c) Women workers between 1900 and 1930
Answer: Participation of women workers was quite
significant in Russia. About one-third industrial workers were women.
Especially during the war years, the number of women workers increased
because the able-bodied men were called for wartime duties.
(d) The Liberals
Answer: Liberals wanted a change in the society. They
wanted toleration towards all religions. They opposed the uncontrolled
power of dynastic rulers. They wanted to safeguard the rights of
individuals. They favoured a representative, elected parliamentary
government. Such a government should be subject to laws interpreted by a
well-trained and independent judiciary. However, some of the liberal
ideas were not democratic. They did not believe in universal adult
franchise and wanted the voting rights only for men with property.
(e) Stalin’s collectivization programme
Answer: Stalin believed that collectivization of
agriculture would help in improving grains supplies in Russia. He began
collectivization in 1929. All peasants were forced to cultivate in
collective farms (kolhoz). The bulk of land and implements were
transferred to the ownership of collective farm. Many peasants protested
such attempts and destroyed livestock to show their anger.
Collectivization did not bring the desired results in the food supply
situation turned even worse in subsequent years.